Sometimes you fume silently and close the browser window, and other times you physically give the screen a curse and a gesture and decide to start a webpage. You know, whatever works.
Gestation and the creation of this site has been brewing for what seems like forever, but it wasn't until today that I decided I've read enough hipster balogna that I couldn't stand it anymore.
The goal of this website is to point out music, movie, and whatever else reviews and articles where the reviewer is either a hipster, elitist, snob, or asshole. I feel there is not enough middle ground in the world of critique. Either someone is a misinformed surface skimmer who lauds any old piece of pop culture garbage and derides the merit of anything new/unfamiliar to them, or is a know-it-all jaded cynic that has heard and seen it all, and is therefore, "Underwhelmed by Life."
I've grown tired of it and someone needs to blow the whistle on these self-important folks. There's not much positivity and encouragement going on in the world of critics,though I suppose the connotation of the word assumes that stance on its own. But maybe, just maybe, we can start to turn it around.
So here's what I aim to do. I will post articles that I believe are unfair and superfluously negative or "underwhelmed." Then, to counter-act that, I will post a response or counter-review to try to even out the scales a little bit. Sound good?
But here's where you, the probably very few at first, readers come in. If you happen to see an article that can at least loosely fit into what I've laid out here, email it to me and I will post it. Nothing is too long or short or irrelevant(maybe)! I want this to be an open discussion on the state of not just critics, but media and culture today in the ole US of A.
Let the fun begin!
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Matt here. I like the idea of your page and can't wait to see where it goes. :)
ReplyDeleteLook up Pitchfork Media's review of The Fragile some time. I don't think it's a solid album - Starfuckers, in particular, is really excruciating - but it deserves a lot better than it got from them.
I feel ya Jarad. Hipsters are a cancer.
ReplyDeleteAnd yes, Pitchfork's review of The Fragile is quite possibly the most condescending thing ever put to pixels.
Possibly my favorite stupid-critique backlash, the greatest band shirt ever: http://www.punkrockpayroll.com/images/odds_ends/full/tees/hellareview_black.jpg
do you remember that review i found in high school? i don't remember which album but i do remember it was about tool and in rolling stone. the guy went on and on with all this crazy shit about ming the merciless' goatee and jungle telegraph hyperdrive drumbeats so much so that you couldn't actually discern his opinion from all the hyperbolic bullshit.
ReplyDeletewhy don't you start a blog: overwhelmed by the thesaurus and flash gordon references.
Well said my friend well said!
ReplyDelete